Book Review: When the Morning Comes

When the Morning Comes (Sisters of the Quilt, Book 2)

Cindy Woodsmall

Synopsis (from publisher):

Her relationship with former fiancé Paul Waddell in tatters, Hannah Lapp has fled her home in hopes of finding refuge with another Amish outcast, her shunned Aunt Zabeth in Ohio. Hampered by limited education and hiding her true identity, Hannah struggles to understand the confusing world of the Englischers and embrace unfamiliar freedoms, but a deepening friendship with the handsome Martin Palmer renews her courage to face the future.

Meanwhile, Hannah’s absence and the distressing events that led to her disappearance create turmoil among her loved ones in Owl’s Perch, Pennsylvania. Her father stubbornly refuses to search for her or to acknowledge increasing signs of instability in daughter Sarah, who suffers secret guilt over her sister’s ruined reputation. Fiancé Paul Waddell is wracked with regret over his betrayal of Hannah’s trust and is concerned with her whereabouts. He befriends Hannah’s remaining allies—brother Luke, best friend Mary, and loyal Matthew Esh—trying to convince them to help search for his love.

First off let me apologize for not putting up as thorough a review as I usually do. This has been an absolutely mad month with NaNoWriMo, and my brain is likely to be pudding for a few weeks yet.

That being said, this is a pretty good book. I read it in a single evening while on a mini-vacation (very mini–one night) in Colonial Williamsburg) because I was interested enough to not want to put it down. The sections that take place in Owl’s Perch drag a bit, especially those with Matthew and Elle, and Sarah’s instability does not ring especially true. Faye is another stock character, but other than those small items the plot moves fairly quickly and the characters are well-drawn.

The only other thing that bothered me about the story was the ease with which Hannah adapted to an Englischer lifestyle. In the course of 2 1/2 years she tosses 18 years of habit and training out the window to do such things as learn to drive a car, wear her hair down, sing with a band, and kiss a man in public. Highly unlikely, but as I am used to reading fantasy it didn’t pull me out of the story all that much.

I was also a bit annoyed that the book ended on a semi-cliff hanger. I don’t like loose ends, and I really don’t like having to wait months (or, heaven forbid, years–Robert Jordan is still on my bad people list because of that, though he’s approaching decades) to find out what happens in the next book.

Other than these nit-picky details, I enjoyed the book. I’ll pass it on to my mother, and then probably to some of the ladies of my bible study group, who I’ve discovered have similar tastes in books (this came out totally by accident, and by the end of the lesson we’d started swapping books and authors).

You know, I need to come up with a rating system if I am going to continue this reviewing business. Stars are so over-done, as are thumbs up/thumbs down and school grades. I need something…something wild. :-) But my brain is too fried to come up with anything right now. Any suggestions?

I know! A contest! I have a free copy (not my used copy either) of When the Morning Comes that I will send to whomever gives me the best rating system. How does that sound?

Looking forward to hearing from you!


  1. Hey! Just got your Christmas letter in the mail with the darling pictures of your Punkin. I’m enjoying reading your blogs and “catching up” with you!

  2. Liz says:

    I actually missed the Amish reference on first reading, but remembered “shunned” from some books I read my kids years back. I like books that people recommend that are so good you read them in one sitting.

    Have a rec for you: El Tigre, which takes place in the 19th century from Prussia to the American frontier. (“El Tigre” is a nickname for a “jaguar,” which tells you a lot about the main character.) There’s a romance/love interest, lots of action and a good bit of history that you don’t notice you’re acquiring because you’re not hit over the head with it. It’s good for young adults/teens and adults. And the hero has a good heart, which I like. It’s well paced and well-written — a great read.

  3. Thanks for the recommendation–I’ll have to look into it!

  4. Cassy Rogers says:

    I have never been so into reading before I got a hold of these books. I have yet to read the third one because I cant find it anywhere.And I am going crazy wondering what is going to happen with Hannah.I just hope the third one dont end on a note that keeps me wondering.Ever since I started reading these books it has made me kind of want to leave my Englisher lifestyle and move into the Plain life,as demanding as it may be.Although my only problem would be wearing those clothes.But it would be worth it if I could run into someone like Hannah.I guess everyone I work with is right I do have an Amish fetish,I cant help it I love these books. Dont stop writing,come out with another series.


  1. [...] This is the first in a new series of books by the author of When the Heart Cries, When the Morning Comes, and When the Soul [...]